Skip to main content

Baking with Betty: Oreo Cheesecakes

As promised, one of our new feature segments is going to feature a most requested recipe, or perhaps a custom recipe debut.  This segment will be posted around the beginning and middle of each month.

My first recipe to share is one I found on a blog back in December.  I wanted something fun to make for a baby shower dessert instead of cake or cupcakes (sooo over done).  That same weekend I also needed a dessert to share for my staff Christmas potluck.  This recipe was the perfect match - something i could make ahead in bulk and plate up as needed for the two parties.  Unfortunately, I did not record where I found the recipe and when I tried to look it up again, I couldn't find it.  So take note - this recipe isn't mine. I will, however, share some tips and variation at the bottom are are my own creation.

Oreo Cheesecake Bites
Makes: 30


42 Oreo, cream-fill chocolate sandwich cookies (30 left whole, 12 coarsely chopped)
2 pounds cream cheese, room temperature
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
4 large eggs, room temperature, lightly beaten
1 cup sour cream
pinch of salt



  1. Preheat oven to 275° F.  Line standard muffin tins with paper liners.  Place 1 whole Oreo cookie in the bottom of each lined muffin cup.
  2. In the bowl of a stand mixer, fitted with the paddle attachment, beat cream cheese on medium-high speed until smooth, scraping down sides of the bowl as needed.  Gradually add the sugar, and beat until combined.  Beat in the vanilla.
  3. Drizzle in eggs, a little at a time, beating to combine and scraping down sides of bowl as needed. Add in sour cream and salt, beat to combine.  Using a large spatula, fold in the chopped Oreo cookies.
  4. Divide batter evenly among the cookie-filled muffin cups, fill each cup almost to the top.  
  5. Bake, rotating muffin tins halfway through, until the filling is set, about 22 to 28 minutes.  Transfer the muffins tins to a wire rack to cool completely.  Refrigerate (in the muffin tins) at least 4 hours (or overnight). Remove from tins just before serving.
This is my ONLY photo of these!

Okay, so I thought I had more photos of these.... Oh well.

Anyway, here are some tips/variations:
  • substituted 1/3 fat cream cheese for full fat
  • substitue reduced fat sour cream for full fat
  • I don't recommend using fat free dairy in baking - it's just weird

  • As pictured, I bought a package of mini oreos (in the lunch snack aisle) and used my mini muffin pan to make a truly "bite" size cheesecake. These were a hit at the lunch time baby shower. 





  • Originally I wanted to use the red Christmas  Holiday Winter Oreos for our "Georgia" themed shower / Christmas, but Publix sold out of them the week of Thanksgiving.  





  • You can use any seasonally colored oreo to make your cheesecakes festive (orange for Halloween, pastel for Easter, etc) 








  • I also wanted to try making these using Trader Joe's Candy Cane Joe Joe's for a mint oreo cheesecake taste...again sold out before I thought of it! 

Comments

Post a Comment

Thanks for reading! We'd love to hear from you!

Popular posts from this blog

Nathan: Six Months

Measurements: Weight:   16lbs 15.5ounces  Length:  27.5 inches Feeds:  nurses 5 times a day; about 10-15 minutes each session. Diapers:    Blueberry Simplex and Smartbottoms size 3 in disposables Clothes:   9 mos and 6-12 mos Shoes:  none Teeth:  two bottoms Firsts & Milestones: Dec 25 - First Christmas Dec 30 - Tried carrots Jan 12 - flu shots + rolled over Likes: Thumb attention from sisters chewing on anything he can baths Disikes: Tummy time realizing he's alone wet diapers  Nathan continues to be a dream baby.  He lives by his schedule. I can almost set my watch to it. 7-8 wake + nurse 930 car nap  10:30 nurse 12 cradle nap 2 nurse 3 cradle nap 5 nurse 730 bath 8 nurse and bath His six month visit didn't go as swimmingly as expected.  Nathan still isn't putting a lot of pressure on his feet (a 4 month mile...

Our Debt Story Part IV: We're Debt Free...now what?!?!

WE’RE DEBT FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Before you celebrate with us, make sure you've read Elizabeth's Story , Eric's Story , and How We Climbed Out of Debt . Two and a half years of gazelle-ish-like intensity + the few months prior as emotional primer and slowed spending, we made it!  We paid off over $50,000.  We have two car titles. Closed credit card accounts. Statements from one student loan (and one on the way!) with a $0.00 balance.  All our debt with Eric’s parents is paid off.  It’s. All. Gone. We also paid for my 3 semesters of grad school in cash.  Paid a second car accident in cash (it was minor compared to the first one).  Went to Nicaraga on a Mission Trip in cash.  Went on a 5 day Puerto Rican vacation in cash.  We’re up to date on medical expenses for the baby in cash.  All while squeezing in travel for weddings , babies, family reunions, half-marathons , mini-vacations and to see out of town friends...in cash! ...

Evie: Five Years

Where has the time gone? Our first born is FIVE! One whole hand.  Three months late is better than never.  We love you sweet Evie Girl! Weight:  48lbs Length/Height:  44 inches  Eats:  3 full meals, 1-2 snacks, 10-15oz of water, 5oz of almond milk Diapers:  Pull Ups at Night Clothes:   6-7 or 7-8 Shoes:  12W Teeth:  All are accounted for, nothing loose yet Sleep:  8pm-7:30am + a rare, but welcomed car nap every few months Milestones: Evie went to PT this year for poor muscle tone and a weak core. A lot of this was due to (but also contributing to) her constipation history. After 4 months of weekly physical therapy and diligently doing her homework, Evie caught up to her peers. She's been seeing another specialist for her tummy.  She's not 100% on her medication, but we haven't had any set backs or any more vomiting or constipation.  Evie can do basic addi...